It’s good enough that I use it every day. The algorithm is not very clever though. For example, let’s say I get to the bottom of my study queue and then study 5 new words. The following day, my review will start by the 15 cards corresponding to my 5 new words instead of mixing them with my 100+ other reviews. I made a complaint about that while I was testing the beta version a few months ago but it’s still not fixed. Also, it seems that the review queue is updated once per day only instead of continuously.
The last release version has a good feel, it’s snappy and I’ve never had syncing issues.
Because it’s good enough, because it’s essentially the only app that let’s you study this way (by literally drawing the characters) and because I’ve already paid my 1 year subscription, I’m sticking to it, but I’m uncomfortable with a few things :
- It seemed to me that it took way too long to reach the current state, which gives me the feeling that, should the app be updated to accommodate new technologies, it would take a long time to be updated.
- There still lacks a lot of features that I would consider bare minimum for that kind of premium price:
- add word via sharing a piece of text in iOS (i.e. select some text anywhere, on a webpage for example -> tap “share” -> tap “add to Skritter” -> a prompt asks in which section of which deck to add the word)
- integration with Midori and other common dictionnaries
- more example sentences
- a less clunky experience to browse user-made decks :
- being able to look inside a deck without adding it to my library
- being able to remove it easily from my library (because I just wanted to look inside in the first place, not add it)
- being able to add my friends’ decks with links without having to browse
- an iPad app that is not a joke :
- meaningfully sized canvas
- use app in landscape too
- split view, slide-over, etc.
- why not have a drawing prompt for multiple-character-words that shows one canvas per character but all at once ?
- Apple Pencil support (should be easy with pencil kit in iOS 13)
- Siri shortcuts integration (to manage decks, words and start study sessions)
This is the bare minimum to justify 15$/month (or 100$/y) for an iOS app in my opinion. I will probably not renew my subscription in November when my current one expires and will maybe come back to Skritter once I judge it’s worth the price.